The big decision/choice on defense is whether to be aggressive or passive. Should I bang down an ace and make a high-risk, attacking play? Or, should I just get out of my own way and let declarer do her own dirty work. Usually, the latter approach is best, but there are many exceptions.
The topic is covered in the book Larry Teaches Defense and the video.
Or try Larry's Defense Webinar series which you can find HERE.
With only your side vulnerable, South opens 2 and North raises to 4. You, West, lead the Q which declarer wins with the ace (partner playing the 5). Declarer plays a low diamond from his hand and your 9 wins (partner plays the 2). Now what?
Vul:South Dir: Both | AQ2 K432 65 AK53 | |
4 QJ109 KJ109 QJ107 | | |
|
.
You have all three side suits well controlled. Declarer will not be able to set up or use any tricks in dummy for discards. The only possible thing he can do with losers is trump them in dummy. He appears to have small diamonds (maybe 4 of them if partner’s 2 shows an odd number of diamonds—count). He wants to trump diamonds in dummy and you want to stop him. Shift to a trump. Whether or not declarer takes the ace now, your partner will get in with his A and continue trumps. Declarer will be unable to ruff any diamonds in dummy and will finish down 1. Without your trump shift, declarer would make the contract—getting to trump a diamond in dummy.
Vul:BOTH Dir: SOUTH | AQ2 K432 65 AK53 | |
4 QJ109 KJ109 QJ107 | K53 865 AQ2 8642 | |
J109876 A7 8743 9 |
You are East. The auction starts 1 on your left and 2 (natural, GF) on your right. Declarer rebids 2 (showing at least 6). RHO jumps to 4 and that is the final contract. Your partner, West, leads the Q to declarer's ace. Declarer plays the 10 to the 5 and 8. You win your K. What next?
Vul: Dir: | A97 543 Q96 AQJ8 | |
| 632 876 KJ87 K96 | |
|
. Make the aggressive switch to a low diamond. Declarer (from the bidding) has 6 spade tricks. From the Q lead, you place declarer with the AK. Once you take your K, dummy has 3 good clubs. Declarer has 6+2+3=11 tricks you know of. If he also has the A, he has the rest. Your only hope is partner has the A. The full deal:
Vul: Dir: | A97 543 Q96 AQJ8 | |
5 QJ1092 A32 7542 | 632 876 KJ87 K96 | |
KQJ1084 AK 1054 103 |
Vul: Dir: | A97 543 Q96 AQ86 | |
| 632 987 KJ5 KJ94 | |
|
You are East. The auction starts 1 on your left and 2 (natural, GF) on your right. Declarer rebids 2 (showing at least 6). RHO jumps to 4 and that is the final contract. Your partner, West, leads the K to declarer's ace. Declarer plays the 2 to the 10 and Q. You win your K. What next?
. Go passive. Return a heart. Declarer has 6 spade tricks, the A, and A. He might (probably) have the A, too, for 9 tricks. There is no source of tricks/discards in dummy. Don’t even dream of switching to diamonds. The full deal:
Vul: Dir: | A97 543 Q96 AQ86 | |
5 KQJ102 108732 105 | 632 987 KJ5 KJ94 | |
KQJ1084 A6 A4 732 |
South opens 2 and North raises to 4. West leads the Q. What is your plan? Assume you win the A, declarer following with the 6. What next?
Vul: Dir: | KQ4 AJ96 75 KQJ10 | |
| 63 K102 A832 9632 | |
|
2.
You should shift to an aggressive, attacking low heart. Why? Declarer likely has 6 spade tricks. If you go passive, he will play clubs, knocking out partner’s A. That will bring his total to 11 tricks (6 spades, 3 clubs, A and K). If declarer has any hearts to lose, you must play one now while partner still has the A. You hope partner has the Q. If declarer has it, there is nothing you can ever do. As you can see, your heart shift sets the contract. Partner puts up the queen and declarer must eventually lose 2 heart tricks in addition to the 2 minor-suit aces.
Vul:Both Dir: South | KQ4 AJ96 75 KQJ10 | |
87 Q84 QJ1094 A75 | 63 K102 A832 9632 | |
AJ10952 753 K6 84 |
South opens 1 raised to 2 and everybody passes. You, West, lead the A and it goes 3,6,2. What do you play to the next trick?
Vul:Both Dir: South | KQ4 543 K92 J974 | |
832 AK10 J106 Q1082 | | |
|
.
This situation screams for passivity. In fact, I think an original trump opening lead is sensible. Now that you’ve led the A and seen the 6, what do you know about the hearts? Partner’s 6 is the lowest spot card so he is discouraging (more on this in Larry Teaches Defense or on the DVD about signals). Partner does not have the Q (or a doubleton). Do not continue the suit, because it could easily look like it does below. A minor-suit switch is dangerous (just look at the harm done by the J or a club switch). Those minor suits are like most suits—he who breaks the suit loses. There is no source of tricks in dummy. No need for aggression. The safe play is a trump. After that, declarer has to do his own dirty work. In the goodness of time, he will likely lose 3 hearts, 2 diamonds, and 1 club.
Vul:Both Dir: South | KQ4 543 K92 J974 | |
832 AK10 J106 Q1082 | 97 J876 A843 K63 | |
AJ1065 Q92 Q75 A5 |
West (You) | North | East | South |
---|---|---|---|
2NT | |||
Pass | 4 | Pass | 4 |
Pass | 6NT |
I'm on the record saying Gerber is a baby food, but I would use it with the North hand.
You lead the Q. Declarer wins it in hand with the K and plays a diamond to the K which you duck, and then the Q which you win. What next?
54 A3 KQJ1095 1098 | ||
Q109 QJ109 A4 Q532 | | |
|
. You know declarer showed 20 or 21 points and dummy has 10 points for 30 points for the opponents. You hold 11. That means partner has zilch (and that declarer chose to open 2NT with 19, as some will do). Yes, you are going to have to pitch a bunch on the diamonds, but you get to pitch after declarer. You can start throwing any suit declarer throws away the jack in. In the meantime, you'll pitch one club and then a heart.
After your defense, partner will offer a likely "I knew we had it beat". The full deal:
Vul: Dlr: | 54 A3 KQJ1095 1098 | |
Q109 QJ109 A4 Q532 | 8762 8762 32 764 | |
AKJ3 K54 876 AKJ |